10 Best Non Toxic Cookie Sheets 2025 in the United States

The GoodCook Everyday Nonstick Carbon Steel Baking Sheet Set, comprising two extra-large 15” x 21” pans, is ideal for those who bake frequently and in large quantities. Made from durable carbon steel, these sheets resist warping and scratching, which speaks to their long-term durability.

The standout feature is the scratch-resistant nonstick coating, ensuring easy release of baked goods and straightforward cleanup. While the set is dishwasher safe, hand washing is recommended to extend its lifespan. The carbon steel construction also promotes even heat distribution, which helps in achieving consistent baking results.

However, the larger size might be cumbersome for smaller ovens or storage spaces, and the heavier weight (2.52 kilograms for the set) could be a consideration for those seeking lighter bakeware.

The HONGBAKE Baking Sheet Pan Set is a versatile and aesthetically pleasing choice for those who prioritize non-toxic materials in their baking tools. Made from 57% thicker carbon steel, these sheets ensure even heat distribution and durability, making them suitable for various baking needs. The diamond texture pattern enhances non-stick properties and promotes even baking, which is a significant advantage for achieving consistent results.

The set includes three different sizes (half, quarter, and jelly roll), catering to a range of baking activities from cookies to roasting vegetables. The Whitford-reinforced coating is free from harmful chemicals like PFOA, BPA, and PTFE, making it a safer option for health-conscious bakers. Additionally, the champagne gold color adds an elegant touch to your kitchenware.

However, there are some drawbacks. The set is not dishwasher safe, which may be inconvenient for those who prefer easy cleanup. Despite the thick material, the maximum heat resistance is 450℉, which might be limiting for high-temperature baking. This pan set is excellent for someone seeking durable, non-toxic, and stylish baking sheets, as long as they don't mind hand washing.

The Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic Baking Sheet Duo consists of two different-sized sheets (18x13 inches and 15x10 inches), making it versatile for various baking needs. Both sheets are made from aluminized steel, ensuring good heat conductivity, and coated with a non-toxic, naturally non-stick ceramic layer. This ceramic coating is free from harmful chemicals like PTFE, PFOA, and PFAS, making it a safer option for your kitchen.

One major advantage is the non-stick property, which reduces the need for excessive grease or parchment paper and allows for easy cleanup. However, the baking sheets are not dishwasher safe, so they require hand washing to maintain their quality. They are also designed to withstand high oven temperatures up to 550ºF, a significant plus for heavy-duty baking or roasting.

With a weight of 7.93 pounds, they are relatively sturdy yet not overly heavy. If dishwasher compatibility is a crucial factor for you, this might be a drawback. The Caraway Baking Sheet Duo is an excellent choice for those seeking non-toxic, versatile, and durable baking sheets, though they require gentle care during cleaning.